In the first instance, I don't think she should have been invited to speak at the U of O at all. While I'm not a conservative, I grant that there are probably countless other conservatives with far more scholarly and worthwhile opinions than Coulter. Coulter is the Howard Stern of political punditry, and the more shocking and offensive her remarks the more she thrives. After all, each time she spouts one of her racist, homophobic, or xenophobic slurs, her name rockets up to the top of the headlines. There is all of zero intellectual content in what she has to say. Nonetheless, she had been invited to speak and the attempt to un-do the mistake is simply a farce.
On a university campus, the way to handle cases like Ann Coulter is pretty simple: pack the audience and ask questions at the end. The stage is as much a platform for her to speak as it is one for her to receive the brunt of criticism and questioning of her dispicable views. Universities are marketplaces of ideas, and there's no doubt that there are enough well-informed, intelligent people there who can handle Coulter's hateful rhetoric.
UPDATE: The news now is that it was the organizers themselves, not the university who pulled the plug on this event. Like several other bloggers and columnists, I was quick to pour scorn on the U of O.
Here's the University's statement on the event:
Dear Alumni and Friends,
On Tuesday, March 23, an appearance by Ann Coulter was scheduled on our campus, organized by the International Free Press Society Canada and the Clare Boothe Luce Policy Institute.
The University of Ottawa has always promoted and defended freedom of expression. For that reason, we did not at any time oppose Ann Coulter’s appearance. Whether it is Ann Coulter or any other speaker, diverse views have always been and continue to be welcome on our campus.
Last night, the organizers themselves decided at 7:50 p.m. to cancel the event and so informed the University’s Protection Services staff on site. At that time, a crowd of about one thousand people had peacefully gathered at Marion Hall.
"Freedom of expression is a core value that the University of Ottawa has always promoted," said Allan Rock, President of the University. "We have a long history of hosting contentious and controversial speakers on our campus. Last night was no exception, as people gathered here to listen to and debate Ann Coulter’s opinions.
I encourage our students, faculty and other members of our community to maintain our University as an open forum for diverse opinions. Ours is a safe and democratic environment for the expression of views, and we will keep it that way."
Nevertheless, Coulter is still playing her martyr card, and Faux News, I'm sure, is crowing right along with her.
h/t to tom for pointing this out in the comments. Thanks!
2 comments:
Martin, I am sure you're aware of this by now, but it was in fact the organizers that canceled. Coulter and her crew probably saw it as an opportunity to make headlines. She is playing the victim card and she likes it. You pointed out, the more outrageous the incident, the more press she gets. Case in point.
What annoys me most is the disinformation that is being spread. Also, Faux news has already had an interview with a Canadian columnist in which they spin the story to imply Canada has no rights and essentially censors every dissenting opinion.
With respect to the Provost of UofO: Yes, the letter was probably a bad idea. However, it was not even close to being an attack or a threat. He said plainly, Canadian laws are different than the USA, therefore she should become aware of our hate speech laws lest she run into trouble.
Thanks Tom. Indeed, the portrayal of the letter as a 'threat' is a gross overstatement. Before the cancellation, I knew the very act itself of sending that letter would only fuel those things you mention in a second paragraph.
Thanks for the clarification.
Post a Comment